If you are in the market for smart speakers, you need to weigh what you want. Is it the Amazon Echo or the Google Home? How to split two of the best devices? I hope we can help.
As you would expect from two of the biggest technical names, both Amazon Echo and Google Home are glossy polished smart speakers, and neither would look out of place at your home. Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant are becoming more mature and useful by the day.
With the Amazon and Google Smart Speakers (and their wizards), you can get answers to questions, set timers and alarms, control smart home devices, and more – all with spoken voice commands.
The Amazon Echo and Google Home devices have a lot in common, but there are also some important differences to talk about. You need to be aware of what you are getting before you part with your hard-earned money.
We know that the Smart Speaker is at the center of most smart homes. But is the Amazon Echo or Google Home right for you? You need to know the following.
TO UPDATE: Amazon has announced a big event in Seattle on September 25th, It is becoming an annual tradition that updated Amazon Echo products will be announced at this time of year. Therefore, we expect many new devices.
We know what you think – at this point we all need to build an extension for our homes to accommodate Amazon's growing echo speaker range.
Frequently Asked Questions about Amazon Echo and Google Home: Here are quick questions answered
Is Alexa better than Google? This is a difficult question because both are similar and we find it difficult to choose between the two. Which one you choose may well depend on which one you personally prefer and what type of product you use, rather than the one that is technically & better; are.
However, Alexa is generally better at supporting a wider range of devices as well as better smart home integration. So if you already have a lot of smart home devices, Alexa may be the best choice.
However, many users who directly compared the two devices believe that Google Assistant might be the smarter solution. And with Google A.I. Learning experience has the greatest potential for the future.
Is there a monthly fee for Echo? No, you do not have to pay anything after buying an Echo product. Although you have some advantages if you are an Amazon Prime member, such as accessing Amazon Music.
Can Alexa visit Google Home? No. Alexa's drop-in feature only works with other Alexa-enabled devices.
What is the difference between Echo and Google Home? As we said above – very little at the moment. Both are very capable intelligent wizards who respond to voice commands and work well with many smart home devices. Read our detailed information below to get a closer look at the details.
Which is the best Alexa speaker to buy? It really depends on what you need. If you want something with a screen, try the Amazon Echo Show. Do you want to save money? Try the budget-friendly Echo Dot. While this guide focuses on echo speakers, Alexa is now integrated with a range of third-party speakers, including the Sonos One.
What works with Google Home? With Google Assistant, you can use your Google homepage to control Philips Hue bulbs, Honeywell thermostats, Nest security cameras, and Smart TVs (if compatible). For more information, see our summary of features in Google Assistant. Visit the Google Assistant Partner page to learn about all the brands Google Home can work with.
Amazon Echo: the different models in comparison
Let's start with the intelligent speaker that started it all. Already in 2014, Amazon brought the echo on the market, and now it is the second-generation model: With a size of 148 mm and a fairly decent sound for its price, which has Bluetooth and WiFi connections, it is a impressive kit. It also shows the distinctive blue ring at the top that tells you when to hear the "Alexa" wording.
Perhaps the most popular echo of all and one of our most popular smart home devices is the Echo Dot – probably because it's the cheapest of the whole group and about the size of a hockey puck, making it a no-stop whine For those who want to try Smart Home Tech for the first time.
The Echo Dot is now available in the third generation and does not offer the best audio quality in this area. It is therefore best for rooms where music playback is not the primary function. However, you can pair it with a Bluetooth speaker or other audio device via an AUX jack, making it a cost-effective upgrade for any older hi-fi system.
Then there's the more expensive 2nd Generation Echo Plus, which is slightly larger than Amazon's vanilla echo and features enhanced sound and built-in features of the smart home hub. This means that it can be more closely integrated with the various other components of the Smart Home Kit that you have installed.
And what about the recently updated Echo Show? Essentially, it's an Amazon Fire tablet with a built-in Alexa-ready speaker, so you can get Amazon Prime Video or the on-screen weather forecast and read the answers. It's a perfect device for the kitchen (think of recipes and watch videos).
Amazon recently released a mini version of the Echo Show, the Echo Show 5. With a 5.5-inch screen, it's designed to sit on your bedside table and still be big enough to watch videos.
The other intelligent speaker in the Amazon Echo series that comes with a screen is the Echo Spot, which you can think of as an improved Echo Dot. This echo is perfect for a bedside table and can make video calls from its round screen.
All of these devices have access to most of Alexa's available capabilities (such as voice-activated apps). However, only the plus can act as a bridge for your smart home devices – while all echo products can communicate with things like smart bulbs and thermostats, only with the plus you can remove individual hubs for each additional gadget family.
All Amazon Echo Smart speakers have a sense of style, as you can see in the pictures above – especially after the last update of 2018 with all the stuff and all those curves. For more information about each Amazon Echo device, see the full test reports below:
Google Home: compared every model
Google's smart speaker offering is slightly smaller than Amazon's. There are four Google Home speakers to choose from, including the recently launched Google Home Hub – the only one with a single screen.
The smallest of the three is the Google Home Mini Speaker. Like the Echo Dot, the speaker is puck-shaped, albeit somewhat pebbly with softer edges, and has a top covered with a fabric speaker net. You can get Google Home Mini in different colors. Four flashing LED indicators indicate when your commands are being monitored and how loud the volume is.
We could face a new Google Home spokesperson very soon – the tech giant is reportedly planning to launch a Nest Mini. This would be a follow-up to Google Home's smallest smart speaker range, similar to Google Nest Hub Max.
In the middle of the range of the Amazon Echo devices is the standard speaker of Google Home, which differs significantly from the Mini. It looks like a small vase with a two-tone design (again, there are several colors available) and a sloping top with a touch panel on top.
The Google Home Max is now more like a conventional speaker and is the largest of the many – it also does not have a comparable Amazon Echo device. The design is boxy and aesthetically closer to the Google Home Mini (with the power speaker cover). Depending on the available space, it can be set up in portrait or landscape format.
While the Vanilla Google Home has a taste for design, both the Mini and Max are subtly attractive and should fit into any environment without much concern.
There's also the Google Home Hub, launched in October 2018, which will directly host the Amazon Echo Show. It can display videos, the weather, recipes, music graphics and much more, but has no camera – so video calling is out of the question.
Last Google published the Nest stroke maxGoogle Assistant puts on a 10-inch smart display. It is the first product to hit the market under the converged brand name Google and the smart home security brand Nest.
Like a larger version of the Google Home Hub, the Nest Hub Max is a large-screen, home-screen smart screen with a front-facing camera for video calls and the ability to remotely check your home.
It's not ready yet, but we've learned that the July 15 release date is set in the US and UK, while Australians should be able to "this winter" (between July and August 2019), according to Google.
For more information on each version of the Google homepage, see the full reviews below:
Keep in mind that with Alexa and Google Assistant, more and more third party vendors are integrating voice assistants into their own products.
So, if there's an audio producer you particularly like, it may be a good idea to wait and see if he has any plans to join any of the smart ecosystems – at this point, it's very likely that nearly all the audio devices in the vicinity are the future be equipped with a kind of microphone and voice control.
Amazon Echo vs Google Home: smart features
The smart features of Google Home and Amazon Echo are broadly similar – talk to them and you can play music, answer common questions, control smart home devices, and set alarms and timers. .. and that just grazes the surface of the Amazon Echo debate against Google Home.
Both Google and Amazon are committed to improving their respective voice platforms over the long term, and both have done a good job of getting third-party smart device vendors – from the thermostat manufacturer to the smart lighting company – their products compatible operation. With a basic level of commands available to everyone, with either a "Hey Google" or a "Hey Alexa" Wake-Up Command, the control of the digital world is just a vibration away from your vocal cords.
Amazon Echo and Google Home speakers differ slightly in the way their capabilities are accessed.
Google Home features are available to all users by default. Unless you're pairing third-party smart home devices with your Google Home system and making a request that the Google ecosystem understands, the required response will be executed without prompting.
Alexa, on the other hand, relies on installing abilities – individual, app-like sets of related voice commands that focus on specific topics or skills. These are managed and activated on smartphones via the Alexa app, and can range from getting information about local transport times to activating voice-activated games.
There is no right or wrong approach – Google's easier, but Alexa encourages faster, more complete development and third-party support.
Amazon Echo vs. Google Home: Audio
As you would expect from such a diverse range of shapes and sizes, you will achieve a very different sound performance in both ecosystems, let alone comparing Amazon Echo to Google Home in general. Here's a broad breakdown of how they sound in relation to each other.
If you can afford only entry-level devices and music continues to be your top priority, choose Google Home Mini, which sounds much better than the Echo Dot. If you do not connect a dot to another speaker via Bluetooth or the 3.5 mm jack, it is simply too thin and too hard to fully enjoy it.
If you are looking for a small echo speaker, the Echo Spot is the best that offers a richer sound despite its size. However, the screen massively increases its cost, keep that in mind.
If you move up the size scale, the Google homepage is too bass heavy for you to really have fun. It also has a lower clarity than the latest generation of the Amazon Echo speaker and the Echo Plus. So, if you limit yourself to $ 100, the Amazon Echo may be the best choice from an audio point of view.
With a low mark-up and Dolby processing, the Echo Plus sound is, as you'd expect, more dynamic than the standard echo.
And the Echo show sounds better than the Echo Plus and Echo despite its appearance, though it is not so dramatic that it forgives some of its other shortcomings.
However, if you're looking for pure sonic superiority between the Echo and Google Home sections, choose Google Home Max. Its bass is well tuned, its mid and high are well defined, and its peak volumes are loud without being overly distorted ,
Amazon Echo vs. Google Home: Price
The two loudspeaker platforms offer such a price range that, to be fair, there is something for every wallet size when it comes to Amazon Echo or Google Home.
It's more about what you expect from your smart speaker of choice: Amazon offers the widest range of options and achieves the cheapest and most expensive prices between the two brands Screen Packaging Echo Show with the Echo Dot at the bottom and the Echo Dot at the bottom at the top. Google, however, sits somewhere in the middle.
You can compare the current prices in the following areas.
Amazon Echo vs. Google Home: Verdict
There is no easy answer to the question of whether you should choose Amazon Echo or Google Home as smart speakers. Both lines are very successful, and as long as you adjust your expectations to the amount you spend on buying in one of the lines, they all sound good enough for their respective price points.
The choice then really depends on the preference of the ecosystem as opposed to the hardware. Are you heavily invested in the services of Google? Then Google Home is probably right for you, as both areas will grow closer together. Google's natural language comprehension is also superior, even if the implementation of the language needs to be further refined.
In terms of the pure price-performance ratio and the already enormous range of its cooperations and abilities, the Alexa devices from Amazon seem to be the more sensible choice in this phase. It's a close race, and Google's powerful search capabilities may be a long-term success. But there is something to say about Amazon's focused approach – in our experience, Alexa currently feels a more reliable assistant. That could change. Either way, place your bets – it is unlikely that you will be disappointed if you choose an Amazon Echo or a Google Home Smart Speaker.
The price written on this page is true as the time it is written. It may change at any moment.